Hi r5868, welcome aboard.
I got serious about shooting BP replica revolvers after getting the 1858 Remington. While the ugliest of the BP revolvers, they just run and run. Colts were always, and still are, very problematic for me. However, there is no revolver more beautiful and accurate than a tuned Colt. The Colts are natural pointers where the long sight radius screams accuracy.
If you truly want to amaze yourself on what a BP revolver can do, get an 1851 Navy. The Pietta 1851 and 1860 comes almost perfect right out of the box and is lower cost than the Ubertis that require some work.
Again, welcome to the most friendly shooting forum on the internet.